According to numerous reports I’ve read, In order to replace the 2.2 Trillion collected in income tax (FY 2023) It would take an average tariff rate of between 58% and 85% on ALL imported goods. That is simply not sustainable and would set off trade wars. Further, the base assumption is flawed that consumption would remain consistent. Most Americans would be far worse off if income tax was replaced with a consumption tax - which all a tariff is.